(Which, I May Destroy You aside, is depressing enough in itself.) But the lack of diversity in nominations would certainly suggest that.Īfter a year that has seen the pandemic worsen racial and gender inequalities, a summer of protests for Black Lives Matter and concerted efforts on the parts of other major film-critic boards to bolster diversity within voters (The Television Academy and the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences to name a couple), the HFPA’s nominations suggest they haven’t really followed suit. Without publishing any diversity figures, it’s impossible to know whether that means film and TV creators are reliant on their work resonating with a majority of older, white men. It’s impossible to know whether screenwriters are reliant on their work resonating with a majority of older, white men. It seems then, since they largely operate as critics, the board of members likely nominates films that resonated with them most – as oppose to noting down public response, although that could play a part for some – as film critics often base reviews on personal opinion. Members won’t know who’s actually nominated until the official announcement when the rest of us find out too. Members select five nominees for each category, rank their choices from 1 to 5 and then The Ernst & Young accounting firm tallies the ballots. They receive dozens of DVD screeners of eligible films, but have most likely already seen them. during the calendar year to be eligible). When it comes to nominating a film or TV show, each member receives a ballot with a list of eligible films and TV shows submitted by studios (they must have opened in the U.S. To watch "Dead Man Walking" and then talk to Tim Robbins about why he made the choices he made to go on set and witness the complexities of filmmaking to talk to costume designers and art directors, those things are invaluable.' 'It’s like being a painter watching Picasso paint and asking, "Why did you use blue?". 'You’re given the opportunity in a master thesis class to talk to people behind the scenes about how things are constructed,' Scott Orlin, who is in his second year as chairman of the HFPA’s board of directors, told Variety last year. They also interview over 400 actors, directors, writers and producers – often reporting from film sets in their daily jobs anyway. Well, HFPA members go to screenings throughout the year, sometimes specifically for HFPA members, sometimes just at a film festival or press screening - according to the Golden Globe website, members usually see more than 300 films overall. ‘ the Golden Globes are given out by people who cover Hollywood, not people who work in the film and TV industries.’ How are Golden Globe Awards nominations decided? ‘Their main journalistic beat must be Hollywood,’ according to Vox. All that is required to be a member – they admit a maximum of five new members every year – is that the journalist must be based in Southern California, but work for a non-US media outlet. According to Vox, the HFPA is a relatively secretive body – there are 90 members – all journalists - but a roster of who they are is not published online. What’s the issue then? Is it that I May Destroy You is so intensely British that it couldn’t possibly ‘speak to’ an American critique? Or, is it that the HFPA is primarily made up of old, white men embedded with so much misogynoir they wouldn’t recognise such an incredible piece of art about sexual assault created by a Black woman even if the world is screaming at them to? And that’s no shade to Emily in Paris, Deborah Copaken, a writer on the Netflix comedy and semi-inspiration for Emily, has said herself that their show being nominated while I May Destroy You was snubbed is ‘what is wrong with everything’. It felt like an absolute certainty it would clean up in awards season, so it feels like a blatant snub when Coel and her show received no recognition at all, while shows like Emily In Paris and actors like James Corden were honoured instead. It tackled the trauma of sexual assault with an intricacy few writers could only dream of and spoke to the sheer genius of Coel like nothing else we watched all year. Immediately trending on Twitter, everyone was asking why and how a show that made such monumental waves upon its release in June last year. If you watched the announcement of Golden Globes nominations last night, you will’ve undoubtedly felt the rage so many of us did seeing Michaela Coel’s I May Destroy You snubbed by the Hollywood Foreign Press Association (HFPA) - the body that decides Golden Globes nominations and winners.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |